reports hero background
UPDATED: Nov 22, 2025

Stock Analysis

AAME Logo
$2.34
-$0.03 |-1.27%
Day Range:
$2.25 - $2.54
Market Cap:
47.93M
P/E Ratio:
10.2826
Avg Value:
$2.48
Year Range:
$1.25 - $3.71
1
General Information
Atlantic American Corp operates in specialty markets within the life and health and property and casualty insurance industries.

The company has two segments: American Southern, It provides property and casualty insurance including bodily injury and property damage liability coverage, uninsured motorist coverage, and physical damage coverage for commercial accounts, and Bankers Fidelity, the company's life and health operations offer a variety of life and supplemental health products including ordinary and term life insurance, Medicare supplement, and other health insurance.

2
Atlantic American (AAME) Stock Graph
3
How We Grade Atlantic American (AAME)

We grade stocks based on past performance, their future growth potential, intrinsic value, dividend history, and overall financial health.

The chart below shows how we grade Atlantic American (AAME) across the board compared to its closest peers.

4
Benzinga Edge Rankings

Benzinga Edge stock rankings give you four critical scores to help you identify the strongest and weakest stocks to buy and sell.

56.8

Growth measures a stock's combined historical expansion in earnings and revenue across multiple time periods, with emphasis on both long-term trends and recent performance.

90.88

Value is a percentile-ranked composite metric that evaluates a stock's relative worth by comparing its market price to fundamental measures of the company's assets, earnings, sales, and operating performance.

Momentum measures a stock's relative strength based on its price movement patterns and volatility over multiple timeframes, ranked as a percentile against other stocks.

56.36

Quality is a composite ranking that evaluates a company's operational efficiency and financial health by analyzing historical profitability metrics and fundamental strength indicators on a percentile basis relative to peers.

Stock Score Locked: Want to See it?
Benzinga Rankings give you vital metrics on any stock – anytime.
5
Peer Ratings

See how Atlantic American compares to its peers in these key performance metrics from Benzinga Rankings.

Top Peers
Value
Quality
Growth
Momentum
Short
Medium
Long
XHGXChange Tec
0
0
10.92
3.08
GOCOGoHealth
0
0.14
29.96
2.76
ZBAOZhibao Technology
86.45
0
0
9.61
HITHealth In Tech
44.52
0
0
0
Short: price trend over the last couple of months
Medium: price trend over the last couple of quarters
Long: price trend over the past year
Stock Score Locked: Want to See it?
Benzinga Rankings give you vital metrics on any stock – anytime.
6
Valuation

Earnings History (3 years)

It is important to look at a companies earnings history to see not only if they are profitable, but if their earnings are growing.
As you can see from the chart above, AAME's earnings have decreased for the past three years, this is a negative sign for the stock.
7
Dividend
There are few things we like to see when evaluating the quality of a company's dividend history and future

Ideally, we would like to see a company have a long history of consistently high dividend payouts that have grown at a consistent rate. From here we want to be confident that this sort of dividend growth and consistency will persist into the future.

The chart below shows the historical trend in Atlantic American (AAME) dividend yield on an annual basis.

289.05%
Atlantic American (AAME) saw a increase in it's dividend yield since 2021
8
Past Performance
How has Atlantic American (AAME) performed over the past 5 years?

The two main factors that we consider when analyzing past performance is overall return and volatility

Using these two metrics, we can determine if this stock gave its investors enough return for the risk that they took on by owning it. This is measured by the sharpe ratio, which has been used as a primary measure of risk/reward trade-off for almost 60 years.

This ratio can be interpreted as the amount of return an investor has received for the amount of risk that they took on by owning the stock over that timeframe.

Atlantic American (AAME) sharpe ratio over the past 5 years is 0.0540 which is considered to be above average compared to the peer average of -0.3077